A healthy living blog from Marshfield Clinic

Urgent care vs. emergency care

graphic illustration of emergency room vs urgent care

Urgent care and emergency care have things in common, but their differences should be most important to you.

Urgent Care: For conditions that aren’t life-threatening

Urgent care is for injury and illness that need care fast but is not life threatening. Board-certified providers treat problems and may suggest follow-up with primary care doctors.

According to Dr. William Melms, an urgent care physician at Marshfield Clinic, “what we don’t want to see are people who’re afraid they’re having heart attacks or stroke. Heart attack and stroke means time is of the essence. Going to urgent care first – delays care.”

His advice: Call ahead so trained staff can help guide this decision.

Some urgent care locations see people when primary care is unavailable, especially in tourist areas. “Our goal is to get those people we see to go to a primary care doctor for follow up,” Melms said.

Emergency Care: When it is serious or life-threatening

Emergency care is for serious medical conditions when delaying care could cause permanent harm or death. It’s not for routine care, said Dr.  Michael J. Schaars, a Marshfield Clinic emergency medicine physician.

Emergency medicine often is referred to as medicine’s safety net because it’s a destination for people to get health care when they don’t have any other place to turn. That applies across the U.S.

“Of all patients we see in the emergency room (ER), not many are true emergencies but some need full ER services,” he said. “We see a lot of need for urgent care and office-based care. For people weighing the differences, seeing their regular doctor is best because they know each other. Urgent care would be quicker and less expensive than in an ER, if appropriate.”

ER patients are seen based on urgency of their situation.

“When it’s busy you may wait,” Schaars said. “It’s not a problem all the time but it will still take longer than expected.”

Schaars said trends in emergency medicine show an ER sees more complicated, older, sicker, more challenging patients. Their care takes more time, too.

Cost can be a factor

Both doctors agree urgent care is more cost-effective, “but sometimes urgent care is not the most appropriate choice,” Melms said. “I’ve had people having a heart attack right in front of me, they know it, but they say the ER is more expensive. The visit is driven by cost.”

ER providers see patients, regardless of their ability to pay, but, said Schaars, “people are paying more out-of-pocket, so it’s important to be intelligent health care consumers. We’re able, capable and willing to take care of patients, but primary and urgent care could be better solutions.”

Emergency Room vs Urgent Care



  1. Aug 16, 2016
    • Kirsten Shakal, Shine365 Editor Aug 17, 2016

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

View our comment policy